Some questions just have to be asked

[katayla]

I've had several Angel vs. Spike discussions lately, so I decided to post a poll to answer that and other questions of similar importance.[Poll #1215050][Poll #1215050]

Comments

[stargazr324.livejournal.com]

They were both so... horrible, and I'm glad the higher ups realized they should not have their heroines end up with either.

David love is always good.

True. I just rewatched season one, so I have Nine on the brain. And I have to say that Ten's tendency to fall in love - a lot - lost him a few points.

[katayla.livejournal.com]

Especially when it comes to Dawson's Creek! It was Dawson's show and he still didn't get the girl. I enjoyed that. :)

Oh, true. I'd say that's probably my least favorite aspects of Ten. Drawn out love stories, like Ten/Rose, are great, but it's never fun to watch a character fall in love in a single episode. I can never quite believe it.

[stargazr324.livejournal.com]

I know! That really said something about his personality, that he ended up alone.

I agree. I love Ten/Rose, but seriously. Madame Pompador (or however you spell it), Joan Redfern, Astrid, River Song... it's just not realistic that given what his life has been like that he would continue to form romantic attachments -- and it cheapens what he had with Rose. Maybe he'll get a male companion next year.

[katayla.livejournal.com]

Especially since . . . I mean, season 3 was so clearly about mourning Rose that it seemed out of character when he'd go and fall for someone else.

I'd enjoy a male companion! I really like it when Jack is on the show (although I guess that's a romantic bond in some people's heads--including, possibly, Jack's!).

[stargazr324.livejournal.com]

Exactly. If they're going to make him into the type of character who falls for someone everytime he's lonely, it's going to get old.

True, but it's more of a romantic bond on Jack's part that the doctor's. At least it would provide some variety!